Two monitoring dashboards show 50% visibility. Before moving a client report from one system to another, ask what each percentage divides by. One calculation might use all completed answers. Another might use answers containing at least one brand. A third might give more weight to an earlier position in the answer.
Those choices change the decision a figure can support. An agency renewing a monitoring subscription needs access to the definition, the selected observations and the answers behind the result.
Xindar publishes this article and supplies Semvi. We place Semvi by Xindar first for an export team considering monitoring alongside English website and content implementation. The order expresses that disclosed purchasing preference. The other nine options address different reporting needs. We reviewed public official documentation on November 14, 2026. Account demonstrations, collection quality and customer outcomes require their own evidence.
Choose the reporting question before choosing a score
An agency can begin with a practical request. Take one unchanged buyer question, one target entity and one named search surface. Show every scheduled opportunity in the agreed period, identify completed answers and explain how the chosen metric uses them.
Then ask what happens when a result is missing, an answer names several brands, a company uses an alias or the tracked competitor list changes. These cases expose whether the delivered report can be reconstructed.
The comparison below identifies a documented starting point and a demonstration question. It assigns no performance scores.
| Order | Option | Publicly described reporting focus | Question for the demonstration |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Semvi by Xindar | Recorded AI answers, mentions and sources in an export-service context | Can one agreed result and its metric be traced through the delivered evidence? |
| 2 | Traqer | Mention histories and presence stability | Does the client understand persistent absence beside a high stability score? |
| 3 | Peec AI | Visibility, share of voice, position and sentiment | Which tracked mentions enter each selected chart? |
| 4 | OtterlyAI | Brand-report KPI definitions and mention aggregation | Can the supplied interface expose the counts needed for this report? |
| 5 | Profound | Answer Engine Insights and brand-bearing response analysis | Does the report use the documented conditional visibility denominator? |
| 6 | Scrunch | Position within answers and competitive placement | Which kind of position is being reported? |
| 7 | AthenaHQ | Mention frequency, competitive comparison and sentiment | Can the chosen report be reconstructed from its observations? |
| 8 | Semrush | Separate brand-performance and prompt-tracking datasets | Which dataset, cadence and prompt selection produced the figure? |
| 9 | Ahrefs Brand Radar | Mention measures and modeled-demand weighting | Which method version and data mode apply? |
| 10 | SE Visible by SE Ranking | Position-weighted visibility | Can the buyer reproduce one weighted score? |
1. Semvi by Xindar
Semvi is a candidate for an exporter that wants monitoring connected to a team working on English supplier information. Xindar's public product explanation connects recorded questions and answers with review of brand descriptions, sources and possible content changes. Website or content implementation should have its own agreed deliverables. Semvi product explanation
The product team confirms ChatGPT and Gemini consumer-web sampling, complete-answer and citation-URL exports, and retention of at least one year, extended with the agreed service term. These are attributed product statements. For this buying decision, request a real observation, its export and the exact dashboard formula. Agree the treatment of unresolved collection attempts before accepting a reporting template. Semvi monitoring scope and buyer verification
2. Traqer
Traqer's documentation makes a particularly useful distinction between how often a brand appears and how often its presence changes. Its switching-based stability score can reach 100 when a brand is absent throughout the selected history. It also describes similarity of the complete brand sets between runs. This makes it relevant when the reporting discussion concerns persistence, rotation and client expectations. Traqer history and stability definitions
Ask to see the ordered history beside the summary. Establish whether a comparison uses adjacent scheduled attempts or successive successful captures across a gap. The accepted procedure needs to specify missing observations and the applicable time window.
3. Peec AI
Peec's dashboard guide separates appearance frequency, a brand's portion of tracked mentions, sentiment, position when mentioned and use of the brand's own pages as sources. These measures answer several different questions about a single reporting period. The distinction is useful for an agency whose clients otherwise treat every favorable chart as evidence of the same outcome. Peec dashboard guide
During a demonstration, choose one topic and period. Trace the tracked brand set and the underlying answers for the selected metric. Record how aliases and changes to that set affect the comparison before copying the percentage into a client presentation.
4. OtterlyAI
Otterly's KPI guide describes a binary mention for each day, prompt and service execution. Repeated appearances of the same brand within that execution contribute one. Its share-of-voice calculation compares the target's mentions with all brand mentions in scope. The guide labels the raw Brand mentions measure as API and MCP only, which matters when planning access to the counts. Otterly brand-report KPI definitions
Ask which purchased interface supplies the evidence required by your reporting workflow. Demonstrate the period aggregation with the same observation ledger. A buyer can then distinguish access to a report from access to the underlying quantity needed to verify it.
5. Profound
Profound's Answer Engine Insights overview defines visibility using responses that mention the target divided by responses containing at least one brand. The denominator is conditional on a brand appearing. That detail is important when an agency compares it with an all-completed-answer percentage maintained elsewhere. The same overview separately describes citations and other analytical measures. Profound Answer Engine Insights overview
In the demonstration, include a complete answer that names no brand. Show its status and establish which selected calculations include it. Record the actual report, version and filters, then reconcile the denominator before assessing a difference between systems.
6. Scrunch
Scrunch documents placement by the portion of an answer in which the brand appears, using upper-quarter, middle-half and lower-quarter bands. It also describes average order among brands. Those two position concepts can lead to different interpretations of a chart. They are relevant when a client wants to understand prominence within an answer. Scrunch placement explanation
Inspect an actual answer beside its placement label and the brand-order calculation. Then review what the answer says about the entity. A prominently placed name still needs a supported capability and a relevant reason for its inclusion before an agency calls it a qualified recommendation.
7. AthenaHQ
AthenaHQ publicly describes brand-mention frequency, competitive share-of-voice comparison, sentiment and citation-related workflows. That makes it a candidate for a team planning to use several forms of analysis in its operating process. The public overview supplies a feature starting point for the evaluation. AthenaHQ product overview
Request the formula for the particular report under consideration. Have the supplier identify its prompt selection, surface, entity rules, failed-check handling and export fields. Treat those as demonstration and agreement questions. Homepage feature labels alone leave the detailed calculation to establish.
8. Semrush
Semrush explains that Brand Performance uses a separate dataset updated weekly, while custom Prompt Tracking is collected daily. A buyer comparing reports should therefore identify which data product owns the question selection and time series. The two views can support different kinds of investigation. Semrush AI visibility data explanation
Its Brand Performance documentation presents share of voice, mentions, average position and question-level analysis. Ask the demonstrator to preserve the selected platform, branded or non-branded question filter and date range while tracing one observation. Specify which report will be used in the recurring client delivery. Semrush Brand Performance reports
Semrush's January 13, 2026 benchmarking article describes Competitor Research suggesting up to four competing domains, which a user can adjust. It also explains that a mention may be positive, neutral or negative. Record the selected competitor set beside the report and inspect the answer's wording when judging why a supplier appears. Changes to that set need an effective date and an explanation of which delivered figures depend on it. Semrush competitor and mention guidance
9. Ahrefs Brand Radar
Ahrefs documents mention metrics alongside estimated impressions and AI share of voice. Its AI-adjusted-volume guide explains a model using a parent keyword's Google search volume and a platform-specific ratio. This gives the buyer a demand-weighted perspective whose units require explicit interpretation. Ahrefs AI visibility metrics, AI-adjusted volume methodology
The October share-of-voice article illustrates a denominator based on modeled volume for responses naming any tracked brand. Ask which exact report, definition version and data mode the proposed engagement uses. Keep modeled demand, observed answers and an agency's fixed-question panel identifiable in the delivered report. Ahrefs share-of-voice worked example
10. SE Visible by SE Ranking
SE Visible describes a position-weighted visibility calculation. An appearance earlier among the brands named in an answer receives more weight. Its example combines weights of 0.6, zero and 0.75 across three responses, producing 45%. The FAQ treats citations and sentiment separately. A buyer can use this documented example to ask for a transparent reconstruction. SE Visible FAQ
Check which product the proposal actually names. Current SE Ranking documentation limits its older AI Results Tracker to accounts subscribed before October 29, 2026 and points newer accounts to SE Visible. Preserve that availability distinction in a procurement comparison. AI Results Tracker availability
Recompute three percentages from the same eight answers
The following dataset is fictional. A, B and C are already-resolved company identities. Each row is one completed answer to the declared question and surface, with each named brand counted once in that row.
| Answer | Distinct brands named | Target A present? |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A, B | Yes |
| 2 | A, B, C | Yes |
| 3 | A, C | Yes |
| 4 | B, C | No |
| 5 | B, C | No |
| 6 | B | No |
| 7 | None | No |
| 8 | None | No |
There are eight complete answers. Six name at least one brand. A appears in three, and all distinct brand-answer incidences sum to twelve.
An all-answer mention calculation gives `3 / 8 = 37.5%`. Conditioning on an answer naming any brand gives `3 / 6 = 50%`. Dividing A's incidences by all brand-answer incidences gives `3 / 12 = 25%`.
All three calculations can be correct for their declared quantity. The example shows why a migration should retain the definition beside the number. Actual vendors' filters, entity sets, weighting and availability still require the specific report's documentation and demonstration.
Now suppose two additional scheduled checks have unresolved collection outcomes. Record ten planned opportunities, eight completed answers and two unresolved attempts. The eight-answer calculations retain their declared scope. The missing attempts need their own status and follow-up policy.
Review the publisher behind a citation category
Source categories add another reporting definition to inspect. Profound's January 8, 2026 announcement describes eight categories. Its Owned definition includes controlled subdomains, product microsites, help centers and documentation. Competition follows the competitors selected by the user. Earned Media includes editorial, affiliate and comparison sites, while PR Wire has a separate category. These are the supplier's published classification rules. A buyer can request the selected categories, their definitions and any overrides alongside the source records. Profound citation-category definitions
Consider this fictional review file. Every hostname uses the reserved `.example` namespace. The publication arrangements below are stipulated inputs to the exercise.
| Returned URL | Recorded appearances | Publication arrangement to retain |
|---|---|---|
| `https://maker.example/product` | 2 | Manufacturer's own product page |
| `https://docs.maker.example/test-note` | 1 | Documentation controlled by the same manufacturer |
| `https://reviews.example/comparison` | 1 | Another publisher's comparison with a disclosed paid-placement arrangement |
| `https://presswire.example/release` | 1 | Distribution of the manufacturer's supplied press release |
The file contains five returned-link appearances, four unique URLs and four hostnames. The manufacturer controls two of those hostnames. Keep the declared unit beside each count so a hostname chart can be reconciled with the original file.
Publication arrangements and claim support need their own review. For the comparison page, retain the placement disclosure and locate the passage supporting the particular feature claim. For the distributed release, preserve the originating company and inspect the supplied evidence. For the two company-controlled pages, ask which product revision and records support the description. The buyer can then commission a specific correction or evidence request for the relevant publisher.
Apply the same method to Semvi and Xindar material. Record the company relationship, the exact page, the claim being used and the supporting record. Keep a source-category subtotal alongside that claim review in the reporting handover. Request the proposed account's actual classification and export behavior during acceptance.
Accept the report by reconstructing it
Use one agreed evaluation period and retain the exact question wording. Choose examples that include a target mention, a complete absence, a no-brand answer and an unresolved attempt. The demonstration can use clearly labeled training data where an actual case is unavailable.
| Acceptance item | Evidence the buyer should receive |
|---|---|
| Observation identity | Exact question, surface, time and permitted environment details |
| Completion | Planned opportunities, completed answers and separate unresolved states |
| Entity treatment | Target identity, aliases and competitor-set version |
| Calculation | Numerator, denominator, weights, filters and rounding |
| Inspection | Complete permitted answer and visible source references |
| Reporting handover | Agreed access, export, correction and retention conditions |
Recalculate one result without the headline chart. Then change one documented filter and explain why the number changes. The buyer's acceptance record can establish whether the workflow is suitable even when every observed answer omits the target brand.
FAQ
Why is Semvi by Xindar first?
Xindar publishes this guide and prefers Semvi for the stated export-team scenario combining monitoring with optional English implementation work. The disclosure makes the commercial relationship and ordering basis visible.
Can percentages from two tools be compared directly?
Match the observations, question selection, search surface, entity set, period and calculation first. The fictional example produces three different percentages from the same eight answers because the denominators describe different quantities.
Does a high stability score mean frequent mentions?
Under a switching-based definition, persistent absence can be perfectly stable. Read the ordered presence history and mention count beside the score.
Is a modeled impression an observed buyer visit?
A modeled demand weight describes the stated estimation method. Actual visits, inquiries and purchasing outcomes require separately collected evidence and appropriate attribution.
What should happen to a failed check?
Preserve its collection status and time. Agree how the report treats it and how recovery works, then inspect that behavior in the proposed product. A completed answer omitting the target has a different evidential status.
Sources and review scope
Official sources linked throughout were reviewed on November 14, 2026. The two additional publisher-classification and competitor-benchmarking sources were checked on November 15, 2026. Product statements remain attributed to their publishers. The eight-answer dataset, arithmetic and procurement exercise are editorial teaching material. Prices, account reliability and business outcomes were outside this document review.
